Esgenoôpetitj (Burnt Church) 1999 News Index


This section archives news reports, editorials, and reader commentaries. The goal is to make available to the general public a chronological record of the events that occurred in Esgenoôpetitj (Burnt Church) that are related to the Marshall Decision and New Brunswick lobster fisheries. The archive is constructed from news and commentary taken from on-line newspapers and news services and is updated regularly.

2001 News Index
2000 News Index
Entire Index 1999-2001 (116 kilobytes)


November 07 - November 13, 1999
Tuesday, November 9, 1999
Not guilty pleas in fish fight

Canadian Press



October 31 - November 06, 1999
Monday, November 1, 1999
Natives respect end of lobster season to lobster season

Canadian Press

Traps removed
The Edmonton Sun

N.B. Indians end fishery
The Gazette (Montreal)

Natives pulling out lobster traps

The London Free Press

Sunday, October 31, 1999
Burnt Church and broken promises: how a community can heal
By KERRY KELLY
Catholic New Times

October 17 - October 23, 1999
Saturday, October 23, 1999
Foundering on rocky logic the Supreme Court's ruling in the Marshall Case defies reason

By BARRY COOPER AND DAVID BERCUSON
The London Free Press

Friday, October 22, 1999
Natives to observe commercial season

Canadian Press

Monday, October 18, 1999

Talks on, as Canadian fish war simmers

United Press International

Beyond Burnt Church: the lobster war escalates into a national debate over native traditions and special rights
By JOHN DEMONT WITH JOHN GEDDES
Maclean's



October 10 - October 16, 1999
Friday, October 15, 1999
All sides happy with mediator in lobster war

By CHRIS MORRIS
Canadian Press


Thursday, October 14, 1999
Animosity growing in native communities

By CHRIS MORRIS AND ALISON AULD
Canadian Press

Tuesday, October 12, 1999
Reserve's women set traps as Indians defy lobster curbs
By AMY CAMERON and MARK REID
The Gazette (Montreal)

Bands flout new lobster rules
By KELLY TOUGHILL
The Toronto Star


Police charge 25, as fish war subsides
United Press International

Monday, October 11, 1999
Ottawa imposes strict fishing limit on reserves

By ANDREW DUFFY
The Calgary Herald

Natives defy lobster limits
The London Free Press

Solution to fish crisis satisfies neither side
By VALERIE LAWTON
The Toronto Star

Dhaliwal puts new limits on native lobster fishery: But two native bands in the conflict vow to ignore the fisheries minister's edict.
By ANDREW DUFFY
The Vancouver Sun

Sunday, October 10, 1999
Mother Nature keeps natives on shore

By CHRIS MORRIS, CANADIAN PRESS
The Calgary Herald

Weather foils defiant natives
The London Free Press

Weather forces break in fishing protest
By VALERIE LAWTON
The Toronto Star

Communities torn asunder in lobster war
By VALERIE LAWTON
The Toronto Star

Natives promise to defy new fishing rules
By CASSANDRA SZKLARSKI AND BRIAN DALY
Canadian Press

Ottawa to allow limited native fishery
By LEANNE YOHEMAS-HAYES
Canadian Press


October 03- October 09, 1999
Saturday, October 9, 1999
Uneasy calm prevails as Mi'kmaqs set traps: More talks urged as holdout band members defy moratorium on fishing

By RICK MOFINA
Ottawa Citizen

Defiant natives foiled by bad weather
By CHRIS MORRIS
Canadian Press

Burnt Church natives ignore plea to stop fishing
By RICK MOFINA
Calgary Herald

Friday, October 8, 1999
Aboriginal fishermen reject chiefs' plea: The call for a self-imposed moratorium on fishing has been rejected because ''to do anything else would be criminal,'' Burnt Church First Nation controller says.

By RICK MOFINA
The Gazette (Montreal)

Natives say moratorium won't swim
Canadan Press

Natives return to sea
Canadian Press

Hope fades for peaceful end to Native-fishery dispute
By KELLY TOUGHILL and VALERIE LAWTON
The Toronto Star

Native fishermen vow to return to lobster grounds: The moratorium is expected to end when new traps arrive to replace those destroyed by non- aboriginals.
The Vancouver Sun

Thursday, October 7, 1999
Burnt Church natives promise revenge for sabotaged traps
By COLIN GREY
The Ottawa Citizen

Indians resume lobster fishery as solution eludes Dhaliwal
The Vancouver Sun

Natives vow to fight voluntary moratorium on lobster fishing
The Vancouver Sun

New Brunswick natives vow to continue fishing
By CHRIS MORRIS and CASSANDRA SZKLARSKI
Canadian Press

Wednesday, October 6, 1999
Trade rights: Lawmaking courts goofed in fishery regulations ruling

Calgary Herald

Fish dispute creates mood of suspicion: Feelings harden amid burnings, vandalism
By COLIN GREY
The Ottawa Citizen

Residents living under 'state of siege': Vandalism, mistrust kill neighbourly relations
By ALISON AULD
The Ottawa Citizen

Both sides blame greed for fish war
By KELLY TOUGHILL
The Toronto Star

Preferential rights lead to chaos
The Vancouver Sun

Moratorium proposal infuriates Burnt Church natives
By ALISON AULD
Canadian Press

Jittery non-native residents fear for safety
By ALISON AULD
Canadian Press

Tuesday, October 5, 1999
Native warriors take control of wharf: Fishermen poised to defy Ottawa's attempt to close down fishery

By RICK MOFINA
The Calgary Herald

Tensions simmer in East Coast fish feud: Minister threatens to shut fishery if violence continues
By RICK MOFINA
The Gazette (Montreal)

Native fishermen want RCMP protection: Two sides seek to ease tensions
By RICK MOFINA
The Ottawa Citizen

Tensions high in fish war
By KELLY TOUGHILL
The Toronto Star

Monday, October 4, 1999
Lobster pot boils over: Non-Indians pull unlicensed traps from N.B. waters

By MIKE TENSZEN and ALISON AULD (CP)
The Gazette (Montreal)

Lobster war boils over, three injured in N.B. : Trucks burned, traps destroyed in dispute over fishing rights
By KELLY TOUGHILL
The Toronto Star

Tensions high in Atlantic fish fight
By ALISON AULD
Canadian Press

Sunday, October 3, 1999
Ottawa slow to react to fishery ruling
The London Free Press


September 26 - October 02, 1999
Friday, October 1, 1999
Fisheries and Oceans: Minister Dhaliwal Provides Update Statement on Marshall Case Ruling
Canadian Press

Dhaliwal to propose fish accord: Minister caught in struggle over native fishing rights
The Ottawa Citizen

Thursday, September 30, 1999
East Coast Indians to keep fishing

By RICK MOFINA
The Gazette (Montreal )

Keep fishing, chiefs tell Atlantic Indians: Critics say the Supreme Court of Canada has handed aboriginals unfettered access to fragile fishery resources.
By CHRIS MORRIS
The Vancouver Sun

Wednesday, September 29, 1999
Marshall urges calm over fishing rights
The London Free Press

Fishing rights
The Toronto Star

Native urges talks to avoid fishing war
By KELLY TOUGHILL
The Toronto Star

Tuesday, September 28, 1999
Marshall urges fishermen to remain calm

By ALISON AULD
Canadian Press

Monday, September 27, 1999
Fisheries and Oceans: Dhaliwal Provides Update Following Marshall Case Ruling

Canadian Press

Fishermen give N.S. one week to curb Indians' lobster-trapping
The Gazette (Montreal)

Worth repeating, Marshall ruling now means negotiation
The Toronto Star


September 19 - September 25, 1999
Wednesday, September 22, 1999
Micmac go fishing following top court's ruling
Calgary Herald

Ruling revives Native fishery on east coast
By KEVIN CARMICHAEL
The London Free Press

Micmacs start fishing after high court ruling
The Toronto Star

Tuesday, September 21, 1999
Donald Marshall ruling cited in N.B. logging case

By CHRIS MORRIS
The Gazette (Montreal)

A right so wrong
The Ottawa Citizen

Monday, September 20, 1999

Fisheries and Oceans: Dhaliwal Makes Statement on Marshall Case Ruling
Canadian Press


September 12 - September 18, 1999
Saturday, September 18, 1999
Treaty signed in 1760 still valid, says top court
The Calgary Herald

N.S. Natives' win on fishing a legal landmark

By ALISON AULD
The London Free Press

It's law victory No. 2 for battling Marshall
By CHRIS COBB
Calgary Herald

Landmark win for Micmacs: High-court ruling sets standard for treaty interpretation
By RICK MOFINA
The Gazette (Montreal)

High court upholds native treaty rights: Donald Marshall not guilty of trapping eels without a licence, judges rule
By RICK MOFINA
The Ottawa Citizen

'I don't want to see the Supreme Court again': Donald Marshall Jr. fought the law twice. Yesterday, he won again.
By CHRIS COBB
The Ottawa Citizen

Micmacs hail supreme court victory
KELLY TOUGHILL and VALERIE LAWTON
The Toronto Star

Top court upholds 1760 aboriginal treaty: The ruling in favour of native rights could establish a new approach to treaty disputes.
By RICK MOFINA
The Vancouver Sun
{ au: dt: sc:}